11 Comments
User's avatar
Kelly E. Keough's avatar

Hi Amy, I saw that you are on Writers at Work and read your post. I wanted to join your Substack because you wrote about A Christmas Carol, my fav. Thanks!

Expand full comment
Amy Makechnie's avatar

It's such a gem - and thank YOU!

Expand full comment
Greg Johnson's avatar

Very nice, Amy. Yes, stories are fundamental to how we understand the world and ourselves. They are vehicles of communication that depend upon our connections to others, and give the lie to the misconception that person-hood depends only on the individual self. The truth is that our first awareness is of other persons, of the warmth of a maternal breast, the wide-eyed face of a parent cooing encouragement to recognition and connection - we know the other before the self. It saddens me when others brag of reading only non-fiction, since they are cutting themselves off from what has always been a precious fount of imagination, the mysterious what-if that deepens our understanding of ourselves and others. Even in the sciences, the proof of a theorem or the marshaling of empirical evidence provides a thrill that goes far beyond the dry Q.E.D. - the trains of thought, the perceptions of connections among concepts, were originally denizens among others of the "fictional" wood of the unknown, and following the paths that led to them in that wood is another kind of "story" that our species seems to crave as part of making sense of ourselves.

Enough blather - thank you, Amy.

-Greg Johnson

Expand full comment
Amy Makechnie's avatar

and thank YOU!

Expand full comment
Linda Williams Jackson's avatar

Love this. A Christmas Carol (every version of it) is one of my favorite Christmas movies, with the Muppets version being the best. :)

Expand full comment
Amy Makechnie's avatar

The Muppets! I forgot they did this. Will have to rewatch!

Expand full comment
Sarah Allen's avatar

Beautiful!! Love this. Scrooge is one of my all-time favorite characters. (And the Pearl S Buck story always makes me cry.)

Expand full comment
Amy Makechnie's avatar

Thank you, Sarah. And yes to crying with Pearl Buck...:)

Expand full comment
Sarah Allen's avatar

My grandpa was a farm boy turned literature professor so that story has a lot of history in my family lol

Expand full comment
Kelly E. Keough's avatar

Hi amy, thanks so much the reply, and for subscribing to my Substack! I’ll be launching soon. Hope to see you on more of Sarah‘s writer’s at work events. I’m looking forward to your newsletters on writing middle grade novels.

Expand full comment
FabFu's avatar

Love the thoughts on a story instead of a pamphlet.

Expand full comment